Water. Tried an experiment the other day. After a run and feeling very thirsty, I took a mouthful but (in the immortal phrase) didn’t swallow. I discovered that the oral sensation of slaking one’s thirst begins to be felt in specific parts of the mouth (establishing that it is not all in the act of swallowing – a remarkable fact in itself.) It seems to be the soft palate and maybe the rear of the tongue that registers that sweet (?) sensation that your thirst is being quenched. Of course it is a bummer if you don’t ultimately swallow the water.
So what is the sensation if it is not taste? I realise this is not a very scientific test since I’m using plain tap water – l’eau ordinaire, if you will – with all its minerals, chlorine, fluoride and who-knows-what oestrogen simulators to flavour it. But I don’t think the quench of the thirst is this.
Wikipedia says simply that, “pure H2O is tasteless and odorless”. The article on thirst says even less about its satiation, except to describe how the desire to drink is triggered but I am no closer to finding the precursor that tells your body to ‘hold on cos here it comes’.
It could be that it is the absence of contaminants that triggers the sensation, rather than the chemical detection of water. So in terms of stimuli, it is simply a matter of detecting the presence of a fluid in the mouth and if it has no taste (or if the taste is of some nutritional substance like sugar), then you are cleared to send it to the back and down the gullet. But you need that positive sensation too, so what is it? Is it more related to touch – pressure and flow and (lack of) texture?
Well, yes, it seems:
Drinking stimulates mechanoreceptors in the mouth and pharynx. These peripheral receptors provide input to the hypothalamus and the sensation of thirst is attenuated. This occurs even before any reduction in plasma tonicity. This may be a safeguard against over-ingestion of water as there is an inevitable delay before the ingested water is absorbed and available to decrease plasma osmolality. http://www.anaesthesiamcq.com/FluidBook/fl5_5.php
So it is all down to “mechanoreceptors”. Hmm. On a hot day, it is also pleasant to dive into cool water, but that is a very different sensation to drinking the stuff. It doesn’t feel like I am simply touching water with my mouth. I can’t think of any candidate but if there was a different liquid substance that is also odourless and tasteless, is also around 1 gm/cc and similarly viscous as water, would we drink it just as greedily? Would it fool our brain? I suspect that the physical properties of this possibly hypothetical substance would have to be so damn close to water before we couldn’t detect the difference, that it would be water. Maybe there are so many properties in addition to the ones I list that, yes, it pretty much defines water. But when you get down to that level – perhaps to the polarity of the water molecules – aren’t you for all intents chemically detecting that it is water? Much as you chemically detect that NaCl is salt? Which is to say, you are in effect tasting it.
Well, there is chemically more to taste than taste, it seems. There is ‘chemesthesis’, which among other things is responsible for tasting (and feeling through the skin elsewhere) chilli hot and menthol cool substances. But no amount of Googling will find a reference to water chemesthesis. (I think I’m ready to cry, ‘I want my umami!’) So while, the qualia of all sensations occur in the brain but are based on stimuli of sensory organs, any perception that water has a taste is almost a pure mental invention. It is just something in the way sH2Oe moves…





