Odourless, colourless… – tasteless?

May 29, 2013

Water.  Tried an experiment the other day.  After a run and feeling very thirsty, I took a mouthful but (in the immortal phrase) didn’t swallow.  I discovered that the oral sensation of slaking one’s thirst begins to be felt in specific parts of the mouth (establishing that it is not all in the act of swallowing – a remarkable fact in itself.)  It seems to be the soft palate and maybe the rear of the tongue that registers that sweet (?) sensation that your thirst is being quenched.  Of course it is a bummer if you don’t ultimately swallow the water.

So what is the sensation if it is not taste?  I realise this is not a very scientific test since I’m using plain tap water – l’eau ordinaire, if you will – with all its minerals, chlorine, fluoride and who-knows-what oestrogen simulators to flavour it.  But I don’t think the quench of the thirst is this.

Wikipedia says simply that, “pure H2O is tasteless and odorless”.  The article on thirst says even less about its satiation, except to describe how the desire to drink is triggered but I am no closer to finding the precursor that tells your body to ‘hold on cos here it comes’.

It could be that it is the absence of contaminants that triggers the sensation, rather than the chemical detection of water.  So in terms of stimuli, it is simply a matter of detecting the presence of a fluid in the mouth and if it has no taste (or if the taste is of some nutritional substance like sugar), then you are cleared to send it to the back and down the gullet.  But you need that positive sensation too, so what is it?  Is it more related to touch – pressure and flow and (lack of) texture?

Well, yes, it seems:

Drinking stimulates mechanoreceptors in the mouth and pharynx. These peripheral receptors provide input to the hypothalamus and the sensation of thirst is attenuated. This occurs even before any reduction in plasma tonicity. This may be a safeguard against over-ingestion of water as there is an inevitable delay before the ingested water is absorbed and available to decrease plasma osmolality. http://www.anaesthesiamcq.com/FluidBook/fl5_5.php

So it is all down to “mechanoreceptors”.  Hmm. On a hot day, it is also pleasant to dive into cool water, but that is a very different sensation to drinking the stuff.  It doesn’t feel like I am simply touching water with my mouth.  I can’t think of any candidate but if there was a different liquid substance that is also odourless and tasteless, is also around 1 gm/cc and similarly viscous as water, would we drink it just as greedily?  Would it fool our brain?  I suspect that the physical properties of this possibly hypothetical substance would have to be so damn close to water before we couldn’t detect the difference, that it would be water.  Maybe there are so many properties in addition to the ones I list that, yes, it pretty much defines water.  But when you get down to that level – perhaps to the polarity of the water molecules – aren’t you for all intents chemically detecting that it is water?  Much as you chemically detect that NaCl is salt?  Which is to say, you are in effect tasting it.

Well, there is chemically more to taste than taste, it seems.  There is ‘chemesthesis’, which among other things is responsible for tasting (and feeling through the skin elsewhere) chilli hot and menthol cool substances.  But no amount of Googling will find a reference to water chemesthesis.  (I think I’m ready to cry, ‘I want my umami!’)  So while, the qualia of all sensations occur in the brain but are based on stimuli of sensory organs, any perception that water has a taste is almost a pure mental invention.  It is just something in the way sH2Oe moves…

The Pursuitists

January 18, 2012

This Saturday, 21 January 2012, is the 223rd anniversary of the death of Baron d’Holbach who, during the Enlightenment, was the first published (albeit anonymously) intellectual to go fully atheist. I only learnt about this figure from a BBC documentary series by Jonathan Miller made in 2004, called A Rough History of Atheism. As Miller notes, d’Holbach appears to be rather forgotten these days. His most famous work is a book called ‘The System of the World’ from which Wikipedia has this interesting quote (in part):

“It is quite natural in man, it is extremely reasonable, it is absolutely necessary, to desire those things which can contribute to augment the sum of his felicity. …but…let him [man] always recollect, that his solid happiness should rest its foundations upon its own esteem,–upon the advantages he procures for others; above all, never let him for a moment forget, that of all the objects to which his ambition may point, the most impracticable for a being who lives in society, is that of attempting to render himself exclusively happy.” From System of Nature, Chapter 15, Part I.

This was published in 1770, six years before the American Declaration of Independence, which has the famous line by Jefferson:

“We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.”

Scholarship on this sentence seems to be divided into the historic antecedents (Locke, Leibniz) of the phrase, ‘pursuit of Happiness’ and its meaning. It does not it seems simply seek to encourage hedonism and seeking purely selfish pleasure.

“…courage and a heart devoted to the good of mankind are the constituents of human felicity, the kindness which is done infers a happiness in the person from whom it proceeds, not in him on whom it is bestowed; and the greatest good which men possessed of fortitude and generosity can procure to their fellow creatures is a participation of this happy character. If this be the good of the individual, it is likewise that of mankind; and virtue no longer imposes a task by which we are obliged to bestow upon others that good from which we ourselves refrain; but supposes, in the highest degree, as possessed by ourselves, that state of felicity which we are required to promote in the world

– Adam Ferguson, History of Civil Society, 1767

If this is what Jefferson meant, it is odd that he did not define his terms in what is after all a legal document (but then the vagueness of the right to bear arms has worse consequences to answer for). This quote seems to invite comparison with The System of the World quote. Notably, Benjamin Franklin had attended d’Holbach’s salon in Paris. So it seems likely that while Jefferson sought the poetry elsewhere, the idea it embodies, of Happiness as a collective rather than an individual pursuit was influenced if not planted by d’Holbach (and other attendees like Diderot).

Sightings

November 27, 2011

House Shrew
Suncus murinus

House shrew, suncus murinus
These guys can be seen mostly at night all over the neighbourhood, moving very fast across open spaces. Supposedly insectivorous, the one above is enjoying corn on the cob.

Colugo
Galeopterus variegatus

More exciting is having a colugo, or flying lemur, glide across the road in front of your car. In these photos it clings to a roadside tree.

Colugo on tree trunk

Colugo climbing

Colugo

Colugo

And in the end, all things must pass…

Colugo faeces

Novocaine Of The World

July 18, 2011

The #NOTW tag is still hot and the News scandal rolls on. Now, it is claiming officials, not just editors. Rebekah gone, Coulson gone, Hinton gone, Stephenson gone, his deputy surely has gone. No politicians or Murdochs yet but the most in trouble are James and Cameron..

What saddens me is to realise despite my early scepticism about Murdoch (I mean from my youth) how much my views about and feelings towards people in the public eye and issues are influenced by Murdoch and other media owners without me really realising it. Sometimes, as with this hacking scandal from the beginning and two years ago, I am left pondering why no one states the obvious. Like when the police said, “Nothing to see here, move along…”, virtually none called them out on it. But that just gives me a despondent feeling since the only reason can be that they are all in on it, press, government, police and you realise that it is not that there is nothing to see but nothing that can be done.

And then you think, ‘and that is Britain. Here, it is 100 times worse’ (the collusion). Or else there is none because you cannot collude with yourself. At least British readers were compensated for their brainwashing with boobs. Template for a (UK) tabloid: front page: here’s what to be outraged by; page two: here’s what to think; page three: ok, Now Stop Thinking, Just Look At Those Enormous…

But here, we are just spied on, told what to think and kept in the dark by the most boring front of total unanimity between media, government, police and the courts. It is like we are on a Novocaine drip. Satisfied by ‘Man Outrages Modesty of Girl in Lift’-type stories. Their is no possibility of outside sensory data getting through to our dulled brains. We can even watch ‘The Matrix’ and not see it as more than a Sci Fi flick without the slightest irony or metaphor. Perhaps even the recent elections were yet more smoke and mirrors to keep us waiting patiently for change we think we ought to want, sort of… ( but George Yeo was quite good actually, and that Tan Kin fellow standing for the Presidency – he’s not totally in the PAP’s orbit, is he) as Singapore has waited for longer than I’ve been here.

A Modern (Singapore) Major-General

May 30, 2011

Tweeted recently but that is not a good format for this.

A Modern Major-General

I am the very model of a modern Major General
I haven’t fought a war but my knowledge is ephemeral
I know the kings of S.E.A. and quote their fights historical
From Lanfang to Demak in order categorical
I was a JC graduate that‘s Raffles Institutional
I got a fine degree that is lucrative yet vocational
Gifted into MIT with a Presidential scholarship
I studied hard and soon acquired a Brigadier-Generalship
With election year impending and my credentials a priority
I ran the army for just a year to prove my superiority
Because In matters of observance of rules authoritarian
I am the very model of a modern Singaporean

From very young the OB markers have been in me ingrainable
I know the history of our nation well except on those detainable
I know the Asian model of government that is consensusorial
And how to lead the nation with benevolence dictatorial
And how the West is so obsessed with its messy demo-craziness
When with a fawn I get by with meritocratic laziness
I understand equations that are social and political
And how to win elections that are entirely hypocritical
So long as in the Media I appear dignified and honourable
The citizens (but maybe not netizens) will be digitally count-on-able
In short, in matters of freedom and rule authoritarian
I am the very model of a modern Singaporean

With tea and resignation I soon joined the PAP
(And thanks are due to Chen Show Mao for declining there to be…)
And so in Tanjong Pagar with a walkover I was electable
And for a junior ministry I was immediately selectable
And now I get a salary that is Super-astronomical
With a job scope with which I can be more than economical
But my military experience will serve me in good stead
And see if I do not put that YOG puppy firmly down to bed
And with populist policies to develop youth and community
I will hopefully achieve 2-Oh-1-6 electoral immunity
But in matters of freedom and rule authoritarian
I am still the very model of a modern Singaporean

– With apologies to Gilbert and Sullivan

One party, won’t mati. Sure, Singapore?

April 17, 2011

A response to Mr Brown’s response to the PM, set to a well-known melody (sorry, I cannot sing to save my life. Well, I could to save my life but all threats short of that are useless).

It is a bit corny but then, nationalistic songs are, by and large, corn-fed and syrupy. But if you are going to moralise to music at least be honest about the subject and not force-feed your desire to shape the nation to your own idiosyncratic liking, namely towards a nation of uniform, unthinking workers and drones:

One people, One nation, One Singapore.
That is what we are told we must be
Working for…

We’ve heard this message for some time.
One voice to hear, one party line.
Some say this means one party,
Some even say the PAP
Should rule over us for evermore…

We should not rock the boat,
Be careful with our vote
And all will be well for Singapore.

One party, won’t mati. Sure, Singapore?
That’s the question we must answer.
We can’t ignore.

Now we hear there is movement on the ground.
Minor parties say good candidates can be found.
They say don’t put all eggs in one basket
Or kena drop then say what – ‘Basket!’??
Must buy insurance policy.

Kiasu Singaporeans
Don’t want to be poor again
Our wealth is in our diversity!

Four parties (or more), For nationhood, For Singapore.
That is what we should be
Fighting for.

Beware the backlash from the PAP.
Using race and religious harmony,
They justify the ISD
To check and balance our liberty
For the rest, got GRC.

But what makes this island strong:
All the Samy, Mat, Lim and John
Celebrating peculiarity.

Four peoples, for nationhood, for Singapore!
That is what is really worth
Striving for.

One society (but many peoples)
Living in harmony
Amidst our diversity
In Singapore…

(orchestral crescendo plays out…)

Hunting the S-quarks

April 14, 2011

If all the political parties in Singapore were lined up, I’d know there was a joke in there somewhere…

But if they were all ranked on a scale from one to ten, what would the poles be? Left, right? Up, down? Charm, strange?? Exactly where do all the various parties lie, ideologically, I wonder. Perhaps they are all over the shop, and I mean each individually; not collectively, which should be normal.

Courtesy of Wikipedia, we have:

  • Democratic Progressive Party – unstated ideology
  • National Solidarity Party – centre-left
  • People’s Action Party – Anticolonialism, Democratic socialism, Social conservatism, Third Way Centrism, Fiscal conservatism
  • Reform Party – Social democracy and free market
  • Singapore Democratic Alliance – Liberal democracy
  • Singapore Malay National Organisation – unstated (political) ideology
  • Singapore Justice Party – unstated ideology
  • Singapore Democratic Party – Liberalism, Liberal democracy
  • Singapore People’s Party – Liberalism, Social liberalism, Liberal democracy
  • Socialist Front – Socialism, Social Democracy
  • Workers’ Party of Singapore – Social democracy

So, there is a spectrum of sorts. Mostly they are democrats with either a liberal or social(ist) leaning. If it wasn’t for the PAP elephant in the corner (or rather, in the centre), they would probably coalesce around the distinct poles and form a two party system like the Republicans and Democrats in the US or liberal and labour parties elsewhere. S-quarks alludes to the zoo of sub-atomic particles that are revealed in nuclear decay. These parties, like the particles, seem able to split and transform from one into another with more flavours than an ice potong man. To date, the PAP has been a lead shield against such beta decay.

Clearly, the thankless task of opposing the PAP behemoth, in which to succeed – one would think – requires all opponents to join there meagre forces, conflicts with the natural desire to politick according to differing ideological standpoints. To stand on a platform of being not-PAP is to acknowledge the enemy as an ideology in and of itself, which validates it as the mainstream alternative. In a sense, there is no electoral politics in Singapore, only referendums on the ruling party that various ad hoc groups (i.e. parties) form periodically in order to advocate a no vote.

But what keeps them from forming at least a three party system, I do not know. Personality, it seems, goes a long way.

I think left and right are these days labels of dubious value except in specific circumstances. But I get the sense that Singaporeans want to debate issues never-the-less and get away from the ‘father knows best’ approach that served older generations. Conventional wisdom suggests that for all its self-renewal, the PAP will be a victim of its own success, sooner or later. From lead shield to just leaden. In other words, that it will fail to properly recognise the moment when its support falters and the consequences will be bad. But bad for who?

I believe that the rulers are sensitive to the ‘ground’ but their methodology has always been to adjust internally to sentiment and respond by decree. All very well when society is happy with a simple feedback system but it sounds like the feedback is now coming from an echo chamber. And there are certain messages that they simply will not countenance, like calls for electoral reform and independent judiciary, press, media, presidency and etc (I could go on but the list is, well, extensive – civic organisations, foreign reportage, human rights organisations, monetary authority, sovereign wealth fund, pluralism…)

Singaporeans have always been attracted to opposition parties even as they voted with the ruling party (I nearly said ‘Government’ but that would be making the same error as the PM) because these other parties provide an outlet for the debate the poeple cannot have with the Government. I think the PAP has understood this and seen it as beneficial to itself. The more colourful the better – the wayang aspect of election rallies. It is a safety valve. And if anyone builds up too big a head of steam, well the Enforcer will deal with them. Perhaps it is not coincidental if his powers as enforcer are these days waning. (But, O! My son, I have taught you well…)

As the electorate gets younger (post-65ers), more educated and more serious, the unwillingness to engage might lead to a ‘freak’ electoral result. Historically, the PAP has always found ways, new measures, restrictions, to ensure this does not happen. It all depends on which has more bodek – the party or the people – to impose their will on the other or otherwise for how much longer the public is willing to angkat bodek.

SOS – Save Our Sinecures

March 31, 2011

General Election coming up. This time featuring the coming out of one young star of the future who among the crop of debutantes we are promised will be Singapore’s 4th PM. Will it be Tin Pot Luck? Or one of the Two Dezzies, sons of MPs and/or ministers? Or a certain Ong, son of another Ong who is an ex-MP? Or maybe a non-Chinese for a change, Mr Putu-piring (barely got steamed about his father). Or the just resigned head of the Monetary Authority? Or the BG who is so competent he is understudying a former PM in his GRC instead of risking untimely defeat in a single member constituency? Only time will tell, or in the words of a song dedicated to Ms Tin, Que Sera Sera.

4th Gen, huh? I must say, over the same time I have only managed to raise one generation. Given that political maturity historically has come mid-way through adult life, Ms Tin notwithstanding, politicians do have a shorter life, it is true. But with the exception of da Man, the brass knuckle fighter, few Party stalwarts these days last until the statutory retirement age they so earnestly want their fellow citizens to NOT reach that they keep raising it. When there is no such thing as electoral defeat and you have a clear field to pick the best and brightest, why such a hasty exit for such gifted people? Renewal? What are they afraid of – corruption? They are too well compensated to be corruptible, right?

Could it be it is part of the deal struck to get them to stand for election in the first place? The deal goes like this:

  1. You don’t have to electioneer, the seat is guaranteed yours in advance – you are too valuable to risk in a contest. If there is a contest, don’t worry, you’ll be teamed with a heavy-weight who Will Not Lose.
  2. For the first year or so you will be on a paid holiday as an MP so you can carry on with your existing career. When you are ready to move into a ministry, don’t worry, because
  3. You will be paid the moon, i.e. an astronomical salary. It will be like a top executive position but with better perks. Plus you can still keep you existing positions outside government. Either the are government linked companies or we will make them so and you can be chairman or a director.
  4. It’s not like it is forever. If you sign on in your 30s, you can retire on full ministerial pension in your late 40s and either return to the glittering career you had before as though it was never interrupted, or if you perhaps hadn’t quite (and this seems increasingly the situation) established yourself, you can move on to begin a glittering career (financially at least) as a top executive or consultant that you may or may not have achieved otherwise. You’ll still have your best golf playing days ahead of you.

Whadya say, huh? Huh? The corollary of early retirement for ministers to make way for a new generation is that the new generation is going to be much younger, or they would have been drafted in the previous election (Ms Tin would barely have been of voting age). So we have a bunch of milksops whose maids are made to carry their army gear. This is the field from which to choose. How sad.

But don’t be down. Ms Tin is there to save the day, straddling as she does 4G and 5G. Except my 2G is not quite playing along. Que Sera Sera.

New clear wave

March 18, 2011

One Malaysian newspaper had to apologise for a cartoon on the Japanese tsunami. I didn’t see it but I wonder if it was anything like the classic image of a giant wave.

Algebra in Egypt: Χρ+[Μ]βαραχ∧(Ωβαμα) = d.Nile

February 1, 2011

Owing mostly to heavy, non-stop rain (I am not talking rain by Brazil or Aussie standards, mind) I spent much the last few days stuck indoors excitedly watching, like (one imagines) a lot of people around the world, tweets, blogs and news reports about the wave of unrest washing over the Middle East. It began in Tunisia (or ‘TuNEEzha’ as Americans tend to say – and, by the way, who says it is only when a BIG country sneezes, the world catches cold? ‘Ah- ah- aah… -Tuneezha’). Now Egypt is running a fever (‘Al- Al- Aaal… Qahirah’) and has a Suez throat. And signs spread that it could yet infect Yemen, Algeria, Morocco and even Jordan, that paradigm of a 20th century enlightened, benevolent despotism monarchy. Announcing a fire sale, various outlets: small, medium to large-sized nations up for grabs. Mostly one owner, careful slave-drivers, low mileage (little progress made). Only co-op bidders need apply (Army generals are deemed ineligible owing to insider trading).

On the sneezing of nations, I keep reading that the origin of the saying (and hence the original geographic references) was the 1929 Wall Street Crash (the sternutation) and related it to Europe (the cold sufferer). Of course, the Great Depression only occurred in those parts of the world, which is why Africa, South Asia and Latin America now boss the West. That aside, none who ascribe this origin to phrases of this type name an actual source (“it is said that” is usual) much less assert who first said it. However, I can now reveal (at least to my limited research ability (aka googling)) that I can trace the origin back at least a century earlier, 1830 in fact and to Metternich, who said, “When Paris sneezes, Europe catches cold”.[1] When Al Zine fled Tunisia, Paris (Sarkozy) held its nose to avoid sneezing.

Now with Egypt we have Tony Blair desperately trying to play doctors and nurses with the regime (while simultaneously avoiding being caught with his pants down …) to prevent a raging epidemic. Epidemic of what? Ayatollaitis? Freedom? Surely he wasn’t hoping for a Peace Prize out of Palestine? Israel can already see the tube station to Cairo being built on the Gaza border with Egypt. They are bound to walk back in.

Χρ+[Μ]βαραχ∧(Ωβαμα) = d.Nile

(Cairo plus Mubarak raised by the power of Obama equals denial.)


[1]Prince Metternich (1773–1859), Austrian statesman. Comment, 1830. attributed, in A Dictionary of Historical Quotations, eds. Alan and Veronica Palmer (1985).


Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free